Neurodivergent Graduate Student Survival Manual
(Note: this page is a draft in progress and is meant to be unpublished at this stage. If you can see this page, please contact us at brandsen@ualberta.ca to let us know. Thank you very much.)
Welcome! This resource aims to help neurodivergent graduate students navigate common graduate school challenges more easily.
Who we are: A primarily neurodivergent team of researchers, faculty, and students created this guide.
What situations does this guide focus on? Our focus is on research-based programs in autism research, psychology, and STEM. Similarly, our understanding of neurodivergence is primarily focused on autism, with some examples related to ADHD, OCD, and rejection sensitivity. Unfortunately, the guidance below may be less applicable to students in other programmes or with other forms of neurodivergence.
Table of Contents
What this Guide Includes
01
Managing Common Challenges
Potential suggestions for specific common challenges in graduate school (time management, handling rejection or setbacks in research, the “hidden curriculum”, etc.)
02
"Should I continue with Graduate School?"
Reflection prompts for students who may be unsure whether they want to continue with graduate school.
03
"Is My Relationship with My PI Healthy?"
A checklist designed to help students identify potential barriers or concerns in their relationship with their supervisor. This covers both egregious concerns and potentially resolvable issues.
04
Feedback Form
At the bottom of this webpage, there is an optional feedback form-- we would love to hear your thoughts and suggestions!
Managing Common Challenges
Below, we outline suggestions for common challenges in graduate school such as procrastination/time management, figuring out when to ask for help from supervisors, dealing with rejection or setbacks, and more.
Click on each section to see the corresponding suggestions!
Disclaimer: We also realize that each person's situation will be unique and suggestions that work for one person may not work for another!
Procrastination or Time Management
Potential workarounds include:
- Optimize your environment to help you focus and feel motivated to work. For example, you might find that working at a library or working next to a friend is helpful.
- Find an accountability partner, where you can have regular check-in meetings and/or shame-free accountability and encouragement.
- Use specific strategies like time blocking (i.e. dedicating each block of time to a specific task), the Pomodoro method (breaking work into intervals), or other strategies that sometimes work for people with ADHD. Click here to read more about time blocking.
- "Eat the frog"-- namely, each time you sit down to work, start with your hardest task or the task you are most dreading. Click here to learn more.
- Create sub-tasks. Sometimes breaking each task into sub-tasks or smaller steps can help one make progress. This can be especially helpful if the larger task feels overwhelming. Likewise, in some cases, starting with the easiest subtask can help one get started and build up a flow to pivot to the harder tasks.
Navigating Independent Work/Vague Research Instructions
Research instructions often have less structure compared to coursework assignments. For example, PIs may give a general idea of what results to look for, but graduate students are often expected to take initiative in finding their own results.
Potential suggestions include:
- Ask for specific, actionable tasks at the end of each meeting with your supervisor or confirm the tasks you plan to focus on between then and the next meeting. Consider also clarifying which tasks are most important versus secondary or supplementary tasks.
- Ensure that your main tasks are prioritised or on schedule before spending a lot of time on the details of secondary tasks (especially if you are someone who tends to get sidetracked easily!).
- Think about key questions. For example, after you find an important result, consider what questions someone might have if you were to present the result to them (you can even talk through it out loud to yourself if that helps.) Over time, identifying these questions can help you figure out what are meaningful next steps for your work and analyses.
- Identify “pivot points” in your tasks (e.g. “if I am very stuck on X, I will work on Y instead” or “if conjecture Z ends up not being true/not yielding meaningful results, then instead of doing follow-up tests on W, it would be more meaningful to shift to T”)
- Ask for specific, actionable tasks at the end of each meeting with your supervisor or confirm the tasks you plan to focus on between then and the next meeting. Consider also clarifying which tasks are most important versus secondary or supplementary tasks.
Identifying when to ask for help
Figuring out when to ask for help can be tricky: on one hand, graduate school is often a time where students are expected to learn to work more independently. On the other hand, supervisors are often willing to help if a student is very stuck.
Potential tips are as follows:
Follow the "chain of supervision" (unless you and your supervisor have worked out a different arrangement). Typically, this chain is:
- Professors will often expect you to try the problem or task yourself.
- If stuck, you can search online to see if there are any related resources/manuscripts/etc. which could help you solve the problem. You could also ask AI to break down the steps for you.
- If still stuck, you can try describing the problem to yourself out loud or clearly writing it down as if you are asking for help (doesn’t always work, but sometimes just formulating the problem clearly can help!)
- Next, you can try reaching out to peers (if applicable) for guidance and then to any postdocs/older graduate students who might be mentoring you
- Finally, if you have tried the above steps or it has been awhile and you are still stuck, you can reach out to your supervisor and/or bring it up in the next meeting
Switching tasks. If you are stuck on something, it is also okay to switch to another task or go do another activity/take a break and potentially come back with a fresh perspective.
Ask your supervisor about their expectations. It’s also okay to directly ask your supervisor when they want you to ask them for guidance versus when they prefer for you to work on things independently
- Professors will often expect you to try the problem or task yourself.
Coping with criticism, academic rejection, and setbacks
Graduate school can feel like a roller coaster– one week, your research may be going quite well, the next week you discover a mistake in your results, and your PI has more critical feedback. This can be particularly amplified for people with rejection sensitivity, PTSD, or differences in emotional regulation.
Potential tips include:
- Maintaining a support system and interest outside of graduate school (as much as is feasible). This can help lessen the sting of rough patches in research or school, and can offer a temporary break from academia. Likewise, the university counselling centre or other resources can help in providing additional support.
- Find supportive individuals within academia. While this may be a simplistic suggestion, a network of supportive peers or mentors in academia may be best positioned to "get" struggles unique to research.
- Give yourself time buffers before making major decisions. For example, some students might feel intense anxiety after receiving a disappointing midterm result or disappointing feedback on their research, and may initially want to withdraw from the course or project. Taking a day or two before contacting the professor or supervisor can help some of the initial anxiety or emotions settle, allowing for clearer decision making.
- Adjust when you check your work email or read feedback if helpful. (E.g. instead of reading feedback right before bed and feeling stressed overnight, you could wait until the following morning when you are more rested and able to begin working on it.)
- Ask your supervisor or collaborators about strengths. It's okay to occasionally ask your supervisor what they think the strengths of a project are, or more generally to communicate that you appreciate knowing what they think is going well as well as what they want you to change.
- Maintaining a support system and interest outside of graduate school (as much as is feasible). This can help lessen the sting of rough patches in research or school, and can offer a temporary break from academia. Likewise, the university counselling centre or other resources can help in providing additional support.
Conflicting access needs (e.g. collaborators with opposite working styles)
One of the great opportunities and challenges of graduate school is collaborating with people who have opposite working styles.
While there are many ways this can occur, we will give two examples below:
Example #1: One team member ("Collaborator A") wants frequent updates/communication, the other team member ("Collaborator B") finds frequent communication overwhelming. Potential options could be:
- Create a Google document or other asynchronous channel where Collaborator A can add as many updates as desired, and Collaborator B can check in at whatever schedule works for them.
- Use one channel (e.g. email) for important updates that are expected to be read, and another channel (Slack, etc.) for lower priority updates where there is no expectation of a response.
- Create a “tiered” update– if length is the issue, Collaborator A can write a brief summary of their update as the main email, and include at the bottom any additional thoughts or supplementary ideas.
Example #2: "Collaborator A" is far more blunt or direct while "Collaborator B" is more indirect or subtle.
- Collaborator B could check whether they are relying on facial expressions, tone of voice, or subtle hints (and, if so, could supplement with more direct or literal communication.)
- Collaborator A could potentially let Collaborator B know that they are a very blunt communicator, and welcome Collaborator B to ask them at any time if they need clarification about something. (E.g. if Collaborator B is worried that a blunt message secretly means Collaborator A is upset with them, they can just check directly.)
- Scheduling periodic structured check ins for feedback (this can be beneficial for collaborations in general, but especially can help identify miscommunications early on when both parties have different communication styles.)
Being distracted by other intense interests
Many neurodivergent individuals can hyperfocus extensively on our intense interests. While hyperfocus can be a wonderful asset and source of joy at times, some may struggle to keep up with research if other intense interests are overwhelming their attention. Potential tips include:
- Blocking off dedicated time for intense interests can ensure that you have time to engage in your interests while also keeping your engagement contained.
- "Fuse" your interests with your research (if possible). For example, there may be research topics at the intersection of your main research and new interests that you could discuss with your supervisor.
- Create a “Rabbit Holes for Later” file to keep track of interesting ideas you would like to delve into when you have time. Saving ideas in a running file might allow one to pause the idea as needed without worrying that it will be forgotten.
- Keep track of which tasks energise or interest you the most (or least, respectively). For example, if you find your attention consistently pulled to specific parts of research, there might be a way for you to take on more of those tasks. Examples of ways that people might customise their graduate school workload (after discussing with their PI) include:
- More or less presenting or poster creation
- More theoretical vs applied research
- More or less mentoring of younger graduate students
- More or less focus on non-research tasks (creating onboarding documents, website management, etc.)
- Preferences for specific parts of a research process (writing the manuscript, literature review, quantitative analysis, qualitative analysis, etc.)
- Blocking off dedicated time for intense interests can ensure that you have time to engage in your interests while also keeping your engagement contained.
"Unwritten rules" or Hidden Expectations
There are often “unwritten rules” in graduate school (sometimes called “The Hidden Curriculum”) regarding time spent in the office, participation in lab activities, expectations regarding email etiquette, etc.
One potential approach could be to ask your PI direct questions about their expectations, such as:
- Are there specific times that you would like me to be in the lab in person?
- Is there any email policy that you would like me to know? (E.g. times a response is expected by, what hours emails are sent, anything else?)
- What would you generally like me to have prepared for each meeting? (E.g. a written summary ahead of time, a short presentation, an informal presentation, something else?)
- Who would you suggest I go to first if I have questions about the project?
- Are there any team activities that you would like all students to participate in? (For example, labs may have optional activities but may still expect students to attend at least a certain percentage of them.)
- Are there specific times that you would like me to be in the lab in person?
Self-advocacy and Disclosure
While unfortunately PIs vary widely in how open they are to self-advocacy from students, some examples of self-advocacy include:
- Asking for adjustments to the work environment (e.g. being able to work in a quieter or more sensory friendly environment, having adjusted hours, being able to work remotely)
- Accommodations related to communication (e.g. having instructions communicated in a specific way, avoiding or using more of specific formats of communication such as email, virtual meetings, in person meetings, etc.)
- More frequent check ins (whether with the PI directly, or with another member of the lab such as a postdoc)
- Asking for extended deadlines on certain non-urgent tasks or requesting deadlines be provided further in advance
- Requesting reduced hours or time away from work
Navigating disclosure is also a common concern in graduate school. There are different types of disclosure, such as:
- Disclosing your neurodivergence or disabilities to the whole team versus to specific individuals. It is also generally best to be very clear and direct if you want people to keep your disclosure private (e.g. if you want to disclose to your supervisor but don’t want them to share it with the group or don’t want them to share it with a specific collaborator) as otherwise there is a risk of your disclosure being shared beyond your comfort zone.
- Disclosing a diagnosis versus a description of it (e.g. “I am autistic, the lights are bothering my sensory sensitivity” versus “I am sensitive to lights, can we turn them down?”)
- Disclosing proactively versus later on. For some people (e.g. those with visible disabilities), disclosure may feel like less of a choice, but there is still the option of disclosing prior to meeting (e.g. via email) or not.
- Asking for adjustments to the work environment (e.g. being able to work in a quieter or more sensory friendly environment, having adjusted hours, being able to work remotely)
Ableism, stigma, and exhaustion
Unfortunately, graduate school isn’t immune from ableism or other types of discrimination, and sometimes this can be exhausting. While unfortunately the following suggestions don’t fully address the problem, they may help you in coping:
Idea #1: Joining a supportive group on campus or in the surrounding area (e.g. a group for ND people or other identity-based groups) can sometimes help in providing a sense of community. There are also online communities (e.g. on Discord, reddit, etc.) for people who prefer more asynchronous or anonymous communication and hobby-related groups for those who prefer to connect over specific interests.
Idea #2: Journaling or counseling can be helpful for some.
Idea #3: In some cases, discussing accommodations or what you need to feel reasonably safe in a lab environment directly with your supervisor can be beneficial. Unfortunately, supervisors may vary greatly in their receptiveness to these topics, and in some cases it may be necessary to only discuss the most important topics or accommodations.
Examples of potential informal accommodations:
- Remote work or flexible hours
- Sensory accommodations (e.g. wearing headphones in the office or having a desk that is further away from crowded areas)
- More frequent check-ins with the advisor
- Specifying a structure for check ins (e.g. first X minutes to present results, next Y minutes for question/discussion, final Z minutes to discuss next steps)
- Written summary of meeting or next steps afterwards, ability to bring an AI notetaker to your meetings
- Additional support for specific tasks you find particularly challenging
- Graduate students with unpredictable stressors (e.g. due to health or family circumstances) may do well with tasks that can be done in spurts over a longer period of time (e.g. writing up results versus appearing in person at a specific time to interview participants)
- Remote work or flexible hours
What if I am really struggling in graduate school?
While stress and being busy are common in graduate school, being constantly overwhelmed or being so busy that it feels impossible to take any time away from research are concerning signs.
In some cases, students who are struggling greatly with graduate school may wonder:
- Is this is a sign that graduate school isn't the right fit for me?
- Is this a sign that I should try to switch research groups and/or research areas?
Should I leave graduate school (and/or leave the group I am in)?
This is a complex and highly personal decision, and the goal of this section is not to make a single recommendation. Rather, we realise that it can be challenging to distinguish between the following two cases:
- Adjustable issues: for example, a mismatch between your research interests or working style that is potentially fixable, addressable issues in your relationship with your advisor, etc.
- More fundamental issues: for example, graduate school feeling difficult because a different career path would be a better fit or issues that are unlikely to be resolvable (e.g. a key accessibility need that is extremely difficult to have met in your field.)
The goal of this section is to provide potential reflection prompts that may be useful, with a caveat that the following prompts don’t cover all possible situations (in particular, they may apply less to situations where extreme stress/extenuating circumstances outside of graduate school are a key factor in decision making):
Potential indications that stress or discontent may be primarily due to the specific lab/environment one is in:
- There are specific stressful practices in my current lab or institution (e.g. long hours, unkind communication from the PI) that could likely be resolved by switching groups or institutions
- There is a specific change or set of changes to my working environment (e.g. accommodations, being able to work remotely, different working hours, etc.) that would substantially improve my experience at work
- I think I would enjoy my research much more if I was focusing on a different topic or if I took on slightly different tasks
- I have enjoyed long term research projects before and/or have enjoyed portions of graduate school
- If I think about the “best case” professional and/or educational trajectory for me, I still picture myself in graduate school (albeit potentially with changes)
Potential indications that staying in graduate school may continue to be stressful (even with adaptations), but still be a worthwhile future investment or worth continuing for the near future:
- I am very close to the end of my degree
- I don’t enjoy graduate school, but have a clear plan for what I want to do after and know that the degree would be required and/or a significant help for my future plans
- For practical reasons (e.g. caring for dependents or similar), I need the financial support or benefits that graduate school provides, at least in the near future
- I don’t enjoy graduate school but don’t have a clear sense of what I would want to do otherwise
Potential indications that staying in graduate school may not be the best choice:
- I don’t think I enjoy research much (for example, this may apply to people who enjoy taking courses, but don’t enjoy applying that in a research setting)
- I can’t imagine a version of graduate school that wouldn’t be very stressful or unpleasant
- I have a clear sense of what I wish I could do outside of graduate school
- Thinking about leaving graduate school feels like a relief (or otherwise brings positive/happy emotions or thoughts)
- If I knew that no one would judge me for leaving graduate school, I would likely want to leave
- One of my main reasons for attending graduate school was because it was recommended by others or seemed like the next step in the academic pipeline
- I have already tried to adjust my environment and tasks as much as possible, but haven’t had success with my current research group or institution (e.g. not able to access accommodations, PI not open to accommodations, lack of other PIs to mentor me);
How can I tell if my relationship with my PI is healthy?
Disclaimer #1: While some elements automatically indicate concern, other elements might be appropriate in certain cases or might reflect an incompatibility rather than misconduct from the PI
Example #1: A PI might temporarily appear to have inequitable treatment between two graduate students such as providing one graduate student with significantly more time and meetings, but this may be explained due to extenuating circumstances in that graduate student’s life or that student having a specific professional milestone approaching on a tight deadline
Example #2: A graduate student might find their PI’s blunt communication style to be very stressful and anxiety inducing, even if the PI’s communication is not unkind or inappropriate.
In general, the more elements that are selected, the higher likelihood the relationship might not be healthy.
Disclaimer #2: What constitutes appropriate professional boundaries may also differ based on field, cultural background, institution, etc. Additionally, many elements can occur on a spectrum and our goal is not to pathologise PIs who have some flexibility in their boundaries.
For example, when it comes to how much PIs share about their personal life with students:
Some PIs might share virtually nothing about their personal life with students
Other PIs might be comfortable sharing a basic overview about their personal life (e.g. if it is relevant to their work schedule or comes up in context, a PI might share briefly that they lost a close family in the past)
However, if a PI is increasingly sharing more and more personal information about their life, only sharing personal information with one student, or sharing in a level of detail that feels uncomfortable or overwhelming to the student (e.g. discussing their experience with grief at length) that can be a red flag
Disclaimer #3: In some cases, a graduate student might find it worth staying in an unhealthy arrangement in graduate school (e.g. if they are close to graduating, if they don’t see a clear alternative, etc.) Likewise, a completely stress-free work environment may be difficult to impossible to find – as such, students may choose to stay with an advisor that they feel is reasonably good overall even if there are some challenges.
Disclaimer #4: Even if an element on the list isn’t objectively wrong, if it is causing you stress; it might still be worth addressing. We hope this list can help students identify very unhealthy supervisory relationships. However, even in more appropriate situations, we hope this list can help students identify areas of their supervisory relationship that might benefit from changes (and, if they feel comfortable in doing so, potentially discuss with their supervisors.)
Inequitable treatment:
Being given less frequent meetings with the PI compared to other students at a similar point in their graduate studies
Being criticized or scrutinized by the PI in a way that other group members are not
Not being given opportunities that the PI gives to other students (for example, learning that the PI regularly suggests seminars or professional opportunities for other students but not to you)
Being consistently treated with less warmth than other labmates
A sense that the PI is avoiding you or keeping interactions to the minimal possible amount
Frequently being given less desirable tasks that your labmates are not or are rarely given (e.g. cleaning equipment, taking on administrative-like tasks, etc.)-- with a potential exception if this is a standard expectation for new students and will be changed as you become a senior student
Special treatment
Your PI gives you compliments that seem overly personal (e.g. detailed compliments about your personality, comments that anyone would be lucky to spend time with you, compliments that your partner is a lucky person)
Comments or compliments about your appearance or weight
Requests from your PI for additional one on one time or more frequent meetings
Having meetings with your PI that feel more like social or casual check-ins (e.g. where most or much of the time is spent on topics unrelated to research)
Having your meetings with your PI scheduled in
Being touched by your PI in a way that feels uncomfortable to you (e.g. your PI frequently putting a hand on your shoulder, hugging you, or otherwise touching you)
Your PI referring to you as their favourite student or otherwise indicating they view your relationship as special or prefer you personally over other students (note: this is distinct from a professor strictly commenting on your academic performance as being remarkable or unique)
Your PI giving you gifts, especially if the gifts are expensive, uncomfortable, or not given to other students (e.g. a standard graduation present or milestone present the PI offers to all)
Triangulation
A professor talking negatively about other group members to you or discussing challenges with them
A professor asking you for advice on other group members, particularly if the question requires in depth analysis of the other group member or help in resolving an interpersonal problem or personal challenge related to the group member
A professor asking you what group members have said about them to you
Conversely, other group members being told about your academic challenges by the professor
Interactions causing you to doubt your memory
Being frequently told by your PI that you are misremembering things
Being told that you were asked to do things (e.g. research tasks) that you don’t remember ever being asked about
Being told that certain interactions didn’t occur, even if you have proof (e.g. email records or corroboration from other lab members) that it did
Being told by your PI that you are misinterpreting or misunderstanding what they said in ways that seem unlikely to you
Overly personal conduct or role reversal
Unsolicited advice or analysis about your personal life (e.g. relationship status, diet, religion or politics, etc.)
Questions about your personal life outside of standard professional small talk or what is relevant to your work, particularly if the questions increase or become increasingly personal over time
Being asked any question about your personal life after you have already indicated that you are uncomfortable with the topic
Being told about highly personal aspects of the PIs life (e.g. being told about details of the PIs relationship problems outside of work, crises or traumas in the PIs life, etc.; beyond a basic overview or what is needed to give context for their work availability)
Your PI frequently asks you for advice about their life or career (beyond asking for your input on shared research projects)
Your PI frequently expresses their struggles, insecurities, or imposter syndrome to you in a way where you feel pressure to reassure them
Having work meetings with the PI in situations that seem unusual to you (e.g. the PI asking you to accompany them to lunch and meet over lunch, or being asked to meet in a more personal setting than their office)
Dual relationships
Your PI is friends with you or has overly friendly behaviour with you (e.g. texting casually outside of work)
Your PI has any kind of overlap outside of work that you feel complicates your working relationship or that hasn’t been addressed (e.g. overlapping with your PI in a small unrelated advocacy, hobby, or religious group or being in an overlapping environment where you might learn personal information about your PI or vice versa)
Your PI has attempted to have any kind of romantic or sexual relationship with you (which is never appropriate)**
Insults or criticism
Your PI criticises you publicly in front of others (i.e. criticising your overall ability or progress, rather than something more limited such as suggesting specific changes to a slide after a group presentation)
Your PI provides overly personal criticism to you in any setting (e.g. describing you as lazy, untalented, weird, etc.)
Your PI yells at you or berates you (outside of an imminent safety hazard such as yelling at you not to add a dangerous chemical combination together in a lab)**
You feel that all or virtually all of your interactions with your PI are highly critical
You feel that your PI blames their mistakes or other’s mistakes on you or “throws you under the bus” (or throws others under the bus)
Your PI treats you reasonably well, but you are concerned with their extreme criticism of a fellow labmate
Tokenisation and microaggressions
Your PI has often made uncomfortable comments about aspects of your identity (e.g. commenting on an accent, gender expression, etc.)
Your PI often assigns you tasks related to your identity (e.g. a PI asking a Black student to review manuscripts for racial sensitivity, without checking first if the student is comfortable or interested in doing so)
You have spent quite a bit of time or energy teaching your PI about aspects of your identity at times (outside of cases where you have volunteered for or enjoy this role)
Your PI has said stigmatising things about aspects of your identity or has made stigmatising assumptions about you (e.g. saying that you can’t be autistic because you are empathetic)
Your PI likes to joke about your or other’s marginalised identities in a way that feels hurtful
Your PI frequently uses the wrong pronouns or name for you, or frequently mispells or mispronounces your name (outside of cases where a PI genuinely is not able to pronounce a certain sound)
Your PI has told other people about personal aspects of your identities (or vice versa, has told you about other collaborator’s personal identities)
Your PI seems reluctant to implement accommodations or is inconsistent in implementing accommodations
Your PI makes overt discriminatory comments (e.g. explicitly saying they would not want a transgender student in their lab, using slurs of any kind, saying students with X identity are worse in some way)**
You have tried to bring up concerns with your PI, but have felt they responded dismissively or defensively
Work-life balance
Receiving (and being expected or encouraged to reply to) emails or communication outside of working hours
Expectation of being in the office outside of working hours
Praise or viewing as positive when lab members work extremely long hours
PI reacting negatively to time away from work for medical reasons (e.g. encouraging you to work through a significant illness or other major personal trauma such as a loss of a loved one, or pushing you to return to work as soon as possible after a major trauma)
PI discouraging you from taking any vacations (e.g. encouraging work over university holidays, over weekends, discouraging use of available vacation hours)
The lab has several after hours events that are technically optional (e.g. socials or optional presentations), but it feels like there are professional repercussions for not attending
Even if your lab does not have strict expected hours, the total amount of work is far more than you can reasonably complete in a standard work week
Predictability
Supervisor frequently cancels or reschedules meetings
Supervisor seems to frequently change research goals (e.g. you often complete a task only to find they decided they want a completely different approach)
Supervisor’s demeanor or communication style seems to change unpredictably (e.g. you feel like you don’t know which version of your supervisor you will get on a given day in a way that is stressful)
Supervisor has extenuating circumstances (e.g. health or family situations) and may be on a leave due to this
Lack of guidance
Your PI has never given you an official onboarding to the lab (e.g. an introduction, introduction to labmates, sense of what the expectations are, etc.) or gave a very perfunctory onboarding
In general, it seems the onus is on you to reach out for scheduling research meetings
Your PI has given no to very little guidance about key milestones throughout the course of your degree (e.g. ensuring you are familiar with requirements and timelines for preliminary exams, forming a thesis committee, suggesting conferences to attend, etc.)
You rarely meet with your PI or only see your PI in group settings
Your PI seems quite disengaged overall
Your PI is generally unresponsive to emails or requests or provides very delayed or minimal responses
At times, key milestones have been delayed, done last minute, or cancelled because you were unable to get in contact with your PI (e.g. a student might be unable to apply for a conference if their PI doesn’t review or sign off on the submission even with adequate advance notice)
Unclear or unpredictable expectations
Your PI often gives you unexpected last minute projects (e.g. an expectation to apply for something on very short notice, an expectation to join a new project that starts immediately)
You are often uncertain what specific tasks are expected of you on what timeframe (e.g. what specifically you should have done by the next research meeting)
There are times where your PI has expected you to take the initiative on something, without it being clear to you (e.g. your PI expecting you to reach out to other professors in the field to build collaborations or mentor/onboard new graduate students; but without any clear or direct discussion to indicate this)
There are times when your PI has been upset with you for not completing a task that wasn’t clearly assigned to you or for not attending an activity or meeting that was listed as optional
Micro managing
Expected individual meetings or check in with professor more than once a week (outside of very busy periods)
Your professor requiring a much greater level of reporting or detail than is typical for your field or that your classmates in other labs experience (e.g. requesting a full report of what was done each day, requiring to be notified of very minor changes that most professors wouldn’t expect)
Going through multiple iterations of minor changes (e.g. revising a figure based on initial feedback, then being asked to further revise minor details of the same figure, then being asked to revise another minor aspect)
Your PI has expectations that are not directly related to your work (e.g. dress code beyond what is standard in your field or required for safety)
Your PI asking you to report information that is not work related (e.g. your diet, what extracurriculars you are involved in, etc.)
Your PI seems to be following you on campus (e.g. appearing in locations you are at more than is warranted by coincidence or professional overlap) or monitors who you talk to
Incompatibility or barriers to communication
You have frequent miscommunications or misunderstandings with your PI
Your PI communicates much more or less directly (and/or bluntly) than you do in a way that adds stress
Your PI seems to often read into your communication or body language in a way that leads to inaccurate assumptions (e.g. assuming you are distracted if you are fidgeting, or assuming that part of an email was passive aggressive or meant something other than what you meant)
A key part of the lab’s environment is incompatible with your needs (e.g. the lab requires or expects in person attendance when you benefit from working remotely as much as possible, the lab is in a location that is far away from the main campus and involves a challenging commute, etc.)
Your PI’s area of research quite different from your research interests
No one else in the PI’s lab has had the career trajectory that you want (e.g. everyone in the lab ends up working in a lab while you want to be a theorist)
Your PI is relatively unfamiliar with the specific area of research or career goal/trajectory that most interests you
Your PI does not check in with you periodically or provide an opportunity to provide feedback
In instances where you have provided feedback, it hasn’t been received well
Emotional impact or indicators:
You feel a high level of stress when thinking about interacting with your professor
You feel or worry that in any interaction with your professor, they will look for things you have done “wrong” (particularly if this worry is relatively unique to them)
You feel you are walking on eggshells (metaphorically) around your advisor
Your experience with your advisor has overall been mentally or emotionally negative in any way
You fear interacting with your advisor in private and try to keep interactions public (e.g. if you know that your advisor is less likely to behave in an inappropriate or angry way in public)
Your interactions with your professor are draining your enthusiasm, passion, or interest in research
You feel isolated or unable to tell others about your experience with your PI
Feedback welcomed!
This page is still a work in progress, and we would love your feedback! In particular, if there are any resources or sections that you think should be added to the guide or parts that you think should be removed or need clarification, please don't hesitate to contact us at brandsen@ualberta.ca.
If you would prefer to use a structured feedback form (which also allows for anonymous feedback), just click the button below!


